Proposed Law changes for 2011
Posted: Fri Oct 29, 2010 6:37 pm
Another board challenged people to come up with ideas for law changes for 2011 they would like to see. Here is my idea of a modest beginning:
In 39-17-1302 Delete sections (a) 6, 7, & 8, section (b) 8, and section (d) 3 & 4. This deals with making it illegal for TN residents (except police and government agencies to possess a "Hoax Device", "Switchblade Knife or Knuckles", or "Any other implement for infliction of serious bodily injury or death that has no common lawful purpose."
A "Hoax Device" is a inoperable explosive device such as a dummy cannon shell, training device, or similar. the intent is to make it illegal to make a false bomb scare. The reality is that the act itself is illegal, but that this section of law makes training devices and deactivated shells illegal to own. To my knowledge, TN is the only state that makes ownership of a dummy mortar shell illegal.
TN defines a "Switchblade knife" as "any knife that has a blade which opens automatically by: (A) Hand pressure applied to a button or other device in the handle; or (B) Operation of gravity or inertia". But makes exceptions for military, law enforcement, and government agencies. So my arthritic hands are not allowed to have any knife which makes it easier to operate. BTW, this would include any normal knife which has had the hinge smoothed so that it can be opened by gravity if you release the lock. This is one of those old 'Jim Crow' laws designed to be used against blacks.
"Any other implement for infliction of serious bodily injury or death that has no common lawful purpose." This is nowhere defined in TN statute. It is unreasonably vague and could include items as diverse as nunchucks, steel bars, and a broken rake. Let's just get rid of it.
In 39-17-1301, delete section (13). "“Restricted firearm ammunition” means any cartridge containing a bullet coated with a plastic substance with other than a lead or lead alloy core or a jacketed bullet with other than a lead or lead alloy core or a cartridge of which the bullet itself is wholly composed of a metal or metal alloy other than lead. “Restricted firearm ammunition” does not include shotgun shells or solid plastic bullets;"
This means that ALL surplus ammo with a mild steel core, or bullets containing steel, bismuth, iron, tin, or copper. Any bullet advertised as 'lead-free' is also illegal in TN. Another stupid law that should just be deleted.
In 39-17-1307, delete section (a)(1) "A person commits an offense who carries with the intent to go armed a firearm, a knife with a blade length exceeding four inches (4"), or a club." I have looked and looked and cannot find a definition of "intent to go armed". I have a hard time believing that a knife blade 4.25" is dangerous, but one 3.9" is not. there are other sections that deal with illegal carry of a firearm. This one is redundant on that issue. and I personally don't have a problem with knives over 4" or clubs being carried by lawful citizens. It's already illegal for felons to go armed at all.
39-17-1351. Handgun carry permits. Why not "Weapon Carry Permits? If you have the right to carry a handgun, why not any other legal weapon? You've passed a handgun safety course, know the law about self-defense, the TBI has certified you as a non-felon. so why limit the permit to just handguns? Right now, if you have a concealed pocket knife, you are technically illegal. If you change the wording of this section, then a lawful permit-holder can legally carry a pocket knife.
In section (p)(1) it states "The department shall charge an application and processing fee of one hundred fifteen dollars ($115)". I propose it be changed to "no more than one hundred fifteen dollars ($115)". I would further add language to this section requiring a full accounting of these funds. I find it difficult to believe that TBI can do a TICS check for $10, but that a handgun permit check costs $100. I would further require that any overage in funds be used to improve and add to the TN public ranges. If the overage is more than $10, then the cost of the permit shall be reduced by $10 for subsequent years
That would be a good start for 2011!!!
In 39-17-1302 Delete sections (a) 6, 7, & 8, section (b) 8, and section (d) 3 & 4. This deals with making it illegal for TN residents (except police and government agencies to possess a "Hoax Device", "Switchblade Knife or Knuckles", or "Any other implement for infliction of serious bodily injury or death that has no common lawful purpose."
A "Hoax Device" is a inoperable explosive device such as a dummy cannon shell, training device, or similar. the intent is to make it illegal to make a false bomb scare. The reality is that the act itself is illegal, but that this section of law makes training devices and deactivated shells illegal to own. To my knowledge, TN is the only state that makes ownership of a dummy mortar shell illegal.
TN defines a "Switchblade knife" as "any knife that has a blade which opens automatically by: (A) Hand pressure applied to a button or other device in the handle; or (B) Operation of gravity or inertia". But makes exceptions for military, law enforcement, and government agencies. So my arthritic hands are not allowed to have any knife which makes it easier to operate. BTW, this would include any normal knife which has had the hinge smoothed so that it can be opened by gravity if you release the lock. This is one of those old 'Jim Crow' laws designed to be used against blacks.
"Any other implement for infliction of serious bodily injury or death that has no common lawful purpose." This is nowhere defined in TN statute. It is unreasonably vague and could include items as diverse as nunchucks, steel bars, and a broken rake. Let's just get rid of it.
In 39-17-1301, delete section (13). "“Restricted firearm ammunition” means any cartridge containing a bullet coated with a plastic substance with other than a lead or lead alloy core or a jacketed bullet with other than a lead or lead alloy core or a cartridge of which the bullet itself is wholly composed of a metal or metal alloy other than lead. “Restricted firearm ammunition” does not include shotgun shells or solid plastic bullets;"
This means that ALL surplus ammo with a mild steel core, or bullets containing steel, bismuth, iron, tin, or copper. Any bullet advertised as 'lead-free' is also illegal in TN. Another stupid law that should just be deleted.
In 39-17-1307, delete section (a)(1) "A person commits an offense who carries with the intent to go armed a firearm, a knife with a blade length exceeding four inches (4"), or a club." I have looked and looked and cannot find a definition of "intent to go armed". I have a hard time believing that a knife blade 4.25" is dangerous, but one 3.9" is not. there are other sections that deal with illegal carry of a firearm. This one is redundant on that issue. and I personally don't have a problem with knives over 4" or clubs being carried by lawful citizens. It's already illegal for felons to go armed at all.
39-17-1351. Handgun carry permits. Why not "Weapon Carry Permits? If you have the right to carry a handgun, why not any other legal weapon? You've passed a handgun safety course, know the law about self-defense, the TBI has certified you as a non-felon. so why limit the permit to just handguns? Right now, if you have a concealed pocket knife, you are technically illegal. If you change the wording of this section, then a lawful permit-holder can legally carry a pocket knife.
In section (p)(1) it states "The department shall charge an application and processing fee of one hundred fifteen dollars ($115)". I propose it be changed to "no more than one hundred fifteen dollars ($115)". I would further add language to this section requiring a full accounting of these funds. I find it difficult to believe that TBI can do a TICS check for $10, but that a handgun permit check costs $100. I would further require that any overage in funds be used to improve and add to the TN public ranges. If the overage is more than $10, then the cost of the permit shall be reduced by $10 for subsequent years
That would be a good start for 2011!!!